Category: Reading

Clarkesworld Issue 222, March 2025

I finally finished reading the March issue of Clarkesworld last week. Here are my brief review of the fiction there.

From Enceladus, with Love by Ryan Cole (4,970 word) — A young teenager stows away on a ship to find her mom on Enceladus, one of Saturn’s moons, where she is a miner. Everything changes when the ship wakes up. A fresh look at a newly awakening AI. (My rating: 5/5)

Pollen by Anna Burdenko, translated from Russian by Alex Shvartsman (5,330 words) — A family is the lead mission to a planet with psychedelic pollen. It hard to say much more without spoiling it. An emotional story of a family dealing with a difficult situation. (My rating: 4/5)

Mindtrips by Tlotlo Tsamaase (7,730 words) — A young woman with a traumatic past is forced to take therapy pills to deal with it so those in authority can figure out what actually happened to cause her mother’s death. Explores the ethics of forcing other to take mental health meds. (My rating: 4/5)

Those Uncaring Waves by Yukimi Ogawa (18,140 words) — A pattern maker who helps to heal people’s pain tries to help a person whose own skin patterns have damaged her mental health. A deeply moving story of helping others for its own sake as well as the importance of having difficult discussions. (My rating: 5/5)

Hook and Line by Koji A. Dae (4,150 words) — An old medium on a generation ship tries to find a way to stay connected to the spirits of those who boarded the ship on Earth. A story about reconciling the past with the future. (My rating: 4/5)

The Sound of the Star by Ren Zeyu, translated from Chinese by Jay Zhang (3,820 words) — A man visits a number of planets where their stars all affect how sound works. For example, on one sound stays available in the atmosphere almost forever. A very unique exploration of sound in our lives. (My rating: 5/5)

Funerary Habits of Low Entropy Entities by Damián Neri (3, 500 words) — A crab-like explorer who subsumes the minds of the dead he eats, finds a dead human, eats it, and builds a spaceship to leave one of Jupiter’s moons. This feels like a scientist wrote it without considering his layman audience. (My rating: 2/5)

The average rating for the stories in this issue: 4.14 out of 5 stars.

More Than Words: How to Think About Writing in the Age of AI by John Warner

I regularly read John Warner’s newsletter “The Biblioracle Recommends”. I thoroughly enjoy his takes on reading and writing there. So, when he started mentioning a book he was working on about the intersection of AI and writing, I was intrigued. I bought a copy on the day of release (4 February 2025) and recently finished reading it.

Warner is a former college writing teacher and currently a columnist for the Chicago Tribune. His book addresses the concern that many have of how the growth of generative AI tools (like ChatGPT) may affect writing and how it is taught. In short, the author’s view is that we are looking at the question the wrong way. In fact, he says that AI can’t read or write. Sure, it produces text through an automated guessing process that churns out grammatically correct text. But that isn’t writing. Only humans can read and write. About the concern of using ChatGPT in education: “Students using ChatGPT to complete assignments that don’t mean anything to them and seem unconnected to learning is only sensible. This is not a character defect of students but the sign of a bad disconnect between schooling and learning.”

The other main idea that I really connected with is that writing is a process not an output. “The economic style of reasoning [that stresses efficiency above all else] crowds out other considerations—namely, moral ones. It privileges the speed and efficiency with which an output is produced over the process that led to that output. But for we humans, process matters. Our lives are experienced in the world of process, not outputs.” Human beings aren’t efficient. Trying to make them so turns us into machines and automatons. This book is well written and essential reading in today’s world.

My rating: 5/5

Mrs. Caliban by Rachel Ingalls

Back in 2017 the movie The Shape of Water was released to box office success and critical acclaim. In November of that same year, this novella, originally published in 1982 and long out of print, was republished. It then found its way onto my list of books. This past week I had some longer than usual drives to scholastic soccer matches that I officiated, so I listened to it on audiobook.

An amphibious creature escapes from a lab where it was being tested on, tortured, and abused. The titular Mrs. Caliban hears about it on her radio as she does her housework. She and her husband are somewhat estranged though still living together. They lost a son to an operation gone wrong and another to a miscarriage. While Mrs. Caliban is preparing and serving dinner for her husband and a co-worker, the monster shows up in her kitchen. She befriends him, hiding him in her son’s old room as her husband never goes to that room or even that part of the house. Mrs. Caliban and the monster have an affair and work on a plan to get him back to his own home in the sea.

Numerous themes and ideas are explored in this short novella. Naturally relationships and fidelity, but also what it means to be a monster and the treatment of non-human animals, including the ethics of eating meat. None of this is heavy handed but occurs in the natural course of the storytelling. Despite being written over forty years ago, it feels surprisingly contemporary. What I appreciate most is that it doesn’t really give answers, though these are implied. Instead, it is a book that questions many things that we often take for granted without even thinking.

My rating: 4/5